Economics, Ethics, and Environmental Policy: Contested Choices
May 2002, Wiley-Blackwell
Economics, Ethics, and Environmental Policy: Contested Choices offers a comprehensive analysis of the ethical problems associated with basing environmental policy on economic analysis, and ways to overcome these problems.
List of Tables.
List of Contributors.
Part I: Introduction.
1. Contested Choices. (Jouni Paavola and Daniel W. Bromley).
Part II: Economics, Ethics, and Policy Choices.
2. Are Choices Trade-offs? (Alan Holland).
3. The Ignorance Argument: What Must We Know to Be Fair to the Future? (Bryan Norton).
4. Benefit-Cost Considerations Should Be Decisive When There is Nothing More Important at Stake. (Alan Randall).
5. Environmental Policy as the Process of Reasonable Valuing. (Juha Hiedanpaa and Daniel W. Bromley).
Part III: Ethical Concerns and Policy Goals.
6. Rethinking the Choice and Performance of Environmental Policies. (Jouni Paavola).
7. What to Do with Inconsistent, Non-Welfaristic and Undeveloped Preferences? (Olof Johansson-Stenman).
8. Awkward Choices: Economics and Nature Conservation. (Nick Hanley and Jason Shogren).
Part IV: Ethical Dimensions of Policy Consequences.
9. All Policy Instruments Require A Moral Choice as to Whose Interests Count. (Allan Schmid).
10. Efficient or Fair: Ethical Paradoxes in Environmental Policy. (Arild Vatn).
11. Trading with the Enemy: Examining North-South Perspectives in the Climate Change Debate. (Bhaskar Vira).
12. Social Costs and Sustainability. (Martin O'Connor).
Part V: Ethics in Aaction: Emperical Analysis.
13. Empirical Signs of Ethical Concern in Economic Valuation of the Environment. (Clive Spash).
14. Motivating Existence Values: The Many and Varied Sources of the Stated WTP for Endangered Species. (Andreas Kontoleon and Timothy Swanson).
15. Environmental and Ethical Dimensions of the Provision of a Basic Need: Water and Sanitation Services in East Africa. (Nick Johnstone , John Thompson , Munguti Katui-Katua , Mark Mujwajuzi , James Tumwine , Elizabeth Wood , and Ina Porras).
Part VI: Conclusions.
16. Economics, Ethics, and Environmental Policy. (Daniel W. Bromley and Jouni Paavola).
Daniel W. Bromley is Anderson-Bascom Professor of Applied
Economics in the Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics
at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. He has written and edited
numerous books including Sustaining Development (1999),
The Handbook of Environmental Economics (1995), Making
the Commons Work (1992), Environment and Economy (1991),
and Economic Interests and Institutions (1989). He is also
the editor of the journal Land Economics, the oldest and most
distinguished international journal in environmental and natural
Jouni Paavola is a Senior Research Associate at the Centre for Social and Economic Research on the Global Environment (CSERGE) at the University of East Anglia and an Associate Fellow at the Oxford Centre for the Environment, Ethics, and Society (OCEES), Mansfield College, Oxford, UK. He has authored a number of publications on economics, ethics, and history of environmental policy.
- offers a comprehensive analysis of the ethical problems associated with basing environmental policy on economic analysis;
- offers practical advice for policy makers by seeking to clarify and defend the ethical foundations of environmental economics ;
- examines what lessons environmental economics should draw from the criticism;
- this contribution is all the more important because the problem has not been extensively studied.