"The secret and importance of mysteries have always been mysteries themselves. This fine analytical study is a five-story library analyzed and mixed into answering the many questions that arise ... (an) exhaustive and comprehensive guide, which needs to be owned and studied by all literary-cultural-crime fiction scholars."
Journal of American Culture

"A lucid and fascinating exploration of the cultural changes that influenced the 19th and early 20th-century development of the genre."
Times Higher Education Supplement

"Rzepka's real strength is his clear, graceful writing which sets his overview apart from its many competitors. In his discussion of the unique sensibility of Sherlock Holmes, the baffling morality of Sam Spade, or the sullied romanticism of Philip Marlowe, Rzepka is as skillful as these accomplished detectives rightly perceiving a depth of complexity, shrewdly identifying their key elements, and clearly tracing their inherent logic Admirably [fulfils] its stated purpose ... to be a stimulating overview of this genre from its origins up to present day and to be read by college undergraduates."
Modernism/Modernity

"Cool, savvy, and utterly compelling: every page of Charles J. Rzepka's magnificent history of detective fiction displays the forensic panache of the true connoisseur of murder. Commanding an unrivalled breadth of reference and depth of insight, the book is a must-read for everyone interested in detective fiction."
Nicholas Roe, University of St Andrews

"In this sustained analysis of the emergence and development of detective fiction in England and America, Charles Rzepka has produced both a compelling cultural history and a skilful demonstration of what Poe aptly called 'the moral activity which disentangles'. It will become an indispensable guide to serious students of detective literature."

Ronald R. Thomas, University of Puget Sound