The Making of Law: An Ethnography of the Conseil d'Etat
December 2009, Polity
What makes this study an important contribution to the social studies of law is that, because of an unprecedented access to the collective discussions of judges, Latour has been able to reconstruct in details the weaving of legal reasoning : it is clearly not the social that explains the law, but the legal ties that alter what it is to be associated together. It is thus a major contribution to Latour’s social theory since it is now possible to compare the ways legal ties build up associations with the other types of connections that he has studied in other fields of acticity. His project of an alternative interpretation of the very notion of society has never been made clearer than in this work. To reuse the title of his first book, this book is in effect the Laboratory Life of Law.
Preface to the English edition vi
1 In the shadow of Bonaparte 1
2 How to make a file ripe for use 70
3 A body in a palace 107
4 The passage of law 127
5 Scientific objects and legal objectivity 198
6 Talking of law? 244
Glossary of technical terms 278
"A fascinating ethnography of a highly renowned but usually opaque French institution, and a welcome foray into the anthropology of law."
EASA Journal of Social Anthropology
"What is legal reasoning? In this lively ethnography, Bruno Latour examines the almost physical work of intertextuality at the Conseil d'Etat, the French supreme court. With his inimitable verve, he shows the fragility and flexibility that secures the force of law."
David Stark, Columbia University
"What if our most subtle observer-theorist of socially constructed knowledge were given total access to a secret, powerful legal institution? The answer to this fantasy of legal scholars is The Making of Law, Bruno Latour's brilliant account of his philosophical fieldwork inside the French council of state. What he finds - the alchemical refinement of legal issues to the point of a purportedly pure legality - will be fascinating for lawyers, comparativists, anthropologists, political scientists, and anyone who cares about how law is made."
Noah Feldman, Harvard Law School
"A completely compelling account of the workings of French administrative law - surely never so closely observed as here - that joins with reflections on scientific authority to initiate comparative anthropology 'all over again'. And we do not have to ask where 'society' is: The Making of Law brilliantly exemplifies the making of society."
Marilyn Strathern, University of Cambridge