Internal Colonization: Russia's Imperial Experience
November 2011, Polity
Starting with the fur trade, which shaped its enormous territory, and ending with Russia’s collapse in 1917, Etkind explores serfdom, the peasant commune, and other institutions of internal colonization. His account brings out the formative role of foreign colonies in Russia, the self-colonizing discourse of Russian classical historiography, and the revolutionary leaders’ illusory hopes for an alliance with the exotic, pacifist sectarians. Transcending the boundaries between history and literature, Etkind examines striking writings about Russia’s imperial experience, from Defoe to Tolstoy and from Gogol to Conrad.
This path-breaking book blends together historical, theoretical and literary analysis in a highly original way. It will be essential reading for students of Russian history and literature and for anyone interested in the literary and cultural aspects of colonization and its aftermath.
Part One. The Non-Traditional Orient
Chapter 1. Less than One and Double
Chapter 2. Worldliness
Part Two. Writing from Scratch
Chapter 3. Chasing Rurik
Chapter 4. To Colonize Oneself
Chapter 5. Barrels of Fur
Part 3. Empire of the Tsars
Chapter 6. Occult Instability
Chapter 7. Disciplinary Gears
Chapter 8. Internal Affairs
Part 4. Shaved Man's Burden
Chapter 9. Philosophy under Russian Rule
Chapter 10. Sects and Revolution
Chapter 11. Re-Enchanting the Darkness
Chapter 12. Sacrificial Plotlines
- This is a radically new account of Russia's cultural history.
- Etkind introduces the concept of 'internal colonization' in order to analyse the history of Russian Empire, culture and literature. By this he means a kind of colonization that involves colonizing one's own people as well as others, something Russia achieved by domesticating its own heartlands.
- Etkind explores serfdom and the peasant commune, as well as the formative role of foreign colonies in Russia, and the revolutionary leaders' hopes for an alliance with the pacifist sectarians.
- Written by a leading scholar in the field, this path-breaking book will be essential reading for all students of Russian history and literature and for anyone interested in the literary and cultural aspects of colonization and its aftermath.
"Thought provoking, at times arguably paradigm shifting"
Slavic and Eastern European Journal
"Internal Colonization might be said to inject postcolonial theory into Russian studies. This, however, would be to understate the case. Russia, in Etkind's account, is no mere latecomer to the postcolonial feast: in so many ways, it got there first. Etkind has confirmed what Russianists have suspected for a while without quite being able to prove the point: that Russia's peculiarly vocal subalterns have at least as much to bring to 'Western' cultural theory as they stand to gain from it."
Times Literary Supplement
"The cumulative power of Etkind's argument constitutes an impressive scholarly achievement, offering a coherent yet richly detailed account of Russia's centuries-long experience of internal colonisation."
Times Higher Education
"A coherent and cogent, as well as an original and witty
investigation … the text itself teems with intriguing
Tristram Shandean excursions."
Journal of European Studies
"Etkind highlights what is at the core of the Russian Empire building process. Beyond objective specific facts [Etkind] goes deep into Russian history and culture to emphasize and explain the heuristic idea 'how to colonize oneself'."
The Global Journal
"A thought-provoking work of scholarship that will inspire both
controversies and useful new approaches to Russian history and
culture: to paraphrase Levi-Strauss, it is good to think
The Russian Review
"A gripping read. Etkind combines an energetic pace with a multitude of sources … Etkind has succeeded in presenting an entirely readable text that will appeal to anyone interested in Russian imperial history, Russian literature, or the literature and culture of a colonial and postcolonial society."
Melbourne Historical Journal
"A fresh and entertaining work that is beautifully written
… Etkind persuasively demonstrates that post-Soviet
postcolonial studies should shift their focus from chasing the
unresolvable historical justice to pursuing original, creative and
challenging research to support competennt discussion of the
Ideology and Politics
"Not only useful but also very enjoyable...It is safe to
consider this as one of the best books of 2011 in its category and
it will definitely have an impact on Russian studies for many years
Journal of Eurasian Studies
"An exhaustingly original book, beautifully written and crafted
so as to be eminently quotable. It will stand for decades to come
as the central volume in the larger debates on empire."
Nancy Condee, University of Pittsburgh
"An erudite and incisive interpretation of Russian history and
culture. Indeed, one of the great virtues of this book is its
sweeping range, covering several centuries of history and culture.
It is well-known that Russia was a great and expansive empire.
Etkind provides a striking new lens for seeing Russian culture and
history, one that stresses the enduring process of internal
colonization. Beyond scholars of Russia, this book should appeal to
those interested in questions of colonialism and post-colonialism
and in issues of comparative empire."
Peter Holquist, University of Pennsylvania
"Combining literary and historiographical evidence, Alexander
Etkind elucidates the processes of 'self-' or 'internal
colonization' the Russian imperial state carried out in its
heartland in tandem with colonizing practices deployed in its
farthest corners. With wit and erudition, Internal Colonization
provides an original and fascinating account of Orientalism's
genealogies, the complexity of its global enactments, and the
fantasia of its imperial, 'self-colonizing' logic on the
newly-illuminated stage of the Second World."
Nancy Ruttenburg, Stanford Center for the Study of the Novel