Working with Problem Faculty: A Six-Step Guide for Department Chairs
September 2012, Jossey-Bass
Problem Faculty: The Number One Concern of America’s Academic Chairs 1
Part One The Six Steps
1. Step 1: Clarify Values and Expectations 11
2. Step 2: Follow Policy 27
3. Step 3: Build Trust with Colleagues 37
4. Step 4: Evaluate Yourself and Your Perceptions 53
5. Step 5: Listen 69
6. Step 6: Take Effective Action 87
Part Two Tough Questions
7. What About the Chronic Poor Performer? 113
8. What About the Passive-Aggressive Colleague? 121
9. What About Bullies? 131
10. What About the Problem Characters Who Emerge During Times of Change? 149
11. What About the Psychologically Impaired? 163
Carolyn Oxenford and Sally Kuhlenschmidt
Appendix A Sample Vision and Mission Statement 193
Appendix B Sample No-Bullying Policy 199
Appendix C Faculty Behaviors That May
Suggest a Mental Health Problem 203
The Author 213
R. Kent Crookston is the director of the Academic Administrative Support Program at the Brigham Young University Faculty Center. In addition to researching academic administration, he currently researches and teaches effective decision-making.
Working With Problem Faculty
San Francisco, CA - Most department chairs come into their position from the faculty and thus have no training in dealing with their colleagues when they exhibit aggressive behavior, bullying, lack of collegiality, or other varieties of challenging behavior. Yet the chair’s ability to handle people and situations appropriately is key not just to his or her success in the role but also to the department’s and its members' ability to function productively.
Rather than looking at the issue systemically, author Kent Crookston provides a practical, focused, on-the-ground approached to help chairs learn to deal with challenging colleagues. Based both on the literature and his own research, Crookston provides six steps for successfully dealing with any kind of a challenging colleague.
- Clarify Values and Expectations
- Follow Policy
- Build Trust with Colleagues
- Evaluate Yourself and Your Perceptions
- Take Effective Action
Working With Problem Faculty answers questions like 'what about bullies?' and 'what about the psychologically impaired?' It is the is a must-read for those department chairs who have to face tough management questions.