Terrorism and Counter-Terrorism: Ethics and Liberal Democracy
January 2009, Wiley-Blackwell
Terrorism and Counter-Terrorism: Ethics and Liberal
Democracy provides sobering analyses of the nature of
terrorism and the moral justification – or lack thereof
– of terrorist actions and counter-terrorism measures in
today's world. Utilizing a variety of thought-provoking
philosophical arguments, the historic roots of terrorism and its
contemporary incarnations are explored in depth. Detailed analyses
of organizations such as the IRA, the ANC, Hamas and Al-Qaeda will
reveal the many faces of terrorism and its disparate motives and
tactics. Discussion of the nature and scope of terrorism and
whether it can ever be morally justified is balanced with analysis
of counter-terrorism strategies and the methods and moral limits of
Terrorism and Counter-Terrorism will greatly broaden our understanding of the nature and morality of terrorism and counter-terrorist pursuits – a crucial precondition for establishing any form of enduring peace between nations in the twenty-first century world.
1. The Varieties of Terrorism.
Terrorism and Counter-Terrorism in the Israeli–Palestinian Conflict.
Terrorism and Counter-Terrorism and the IRA in Northern Ireland.
The African National Congress’s Armed Struggle in Apartheid South Africa.
Terrorism and Counter-Terrorism in India.
2. Defining Terrorism.
The Definition of Terrorism in Terms of Innocents.
The Definition of Terrorism in Terms of Non-Combatants.
Terrorism, Combatants and Authoritarian States.
The Definition of Terrorism: An Indirect Strategy.
3. Terrorism and Collective Responsibility.
Moral Justification for the Use of Deadly Force.
Civilian Immunity and Human Rights Violations.
Civilian Immunity and Culpable Omissions.
Terrorism and Non-Violent Rights Violators.
Terrorism-as-Crime and Police Institutions.
Counter-Terrorism and Human Rights in Liberal Democracies at Peace.
5. Terrorism, War and States of Emergency.
Terrorist Attacks, Disasters and States of Emergency.
Terrorism, Internal Armed Struggles and Theatres of War.
Targeted Killings and the Problem of Dirty Hands.
Definition of Torture.
What Is Wrong with Torture?.
The Moral Justification for One-Off Acts of Torture in Emergencies.
The Moral Justification for Legalized and Institutionalized Torture.
7. Bioterrorism and the Dual-Use Dilemma.
The Biological Weapons Convention.
Experiments of Concern.
Dual-Use Research: The Ethical Issues.
Dissemination of Dual-Use Research Results.
The Regulation of Dual-Use Research.
An Independent Authority.
- Integrates thoughtful ethical-philosophical analyses with
contemporary terrorist organizations
- Offers a liberal and human rights-based perspective that takes
contemporary security challenges seriously
- Considers the ethics of a wide range of counter-terrorism
techniques, including prolonged detention, surveillance, torture,
and targeted killing
- Accessible and analytical, while offering practical solutions
to ethical dilemmas posed by terrorism.
"[Miller's] book is seminal in its suggestion of re-establishing
the political role of philosophical
reason for dealing with the problems of our age." (Mehmet Ruhi Demiray, Political Studies Review, 2011, vol. 9)
"Seumas Miller's book is entitled Terrorism and Counter-Terrorism but it is much more than its title suggests. It is best described as an astute examination of the different types of ‘unconventional political violence' that occur in our world. It provides useful discussions of political assassinations, targeted killings, torture, attacks on military personnel who do not perceive themselves to be at war, and more. Miller is especially concerned about the appropriate response to terrorism-whether it is fighting crime or engaging in war. He is also concerned with how liberal democracies can most effectively respond to terrorism without violating their most basic moral commitments. . . there is much in the book that can advance discussion of some of the most important issues facing Western liberal democracies." (Australasian Journal of Philosophy, 12 May 2011)
"Seumas Miller has written a first-rate book. It is the only philosophical treatment of the ethics of terrorism that takes counter-terrorism seriously. Building on his extensive work in police ethics, Miller refocuses the debate about terrorism in light of the kind of procedures that police and the military employ to stop it. It greatly contributes to enlarging the growing debates about the appropriate moral response to terrorism.’– Larry May, Washington University in St Louis
'Miller's book is a serious invitation to think again through complex issues, about whether terrorism is ever justifiable, about the "police" versus "war" paradigms of counter-terrorism, and about torture... In general, Miller's mode of argument is pleasingly generous, pointing out difficulties and counter-arguments along the way." The Guardian