LEARNING OBJECTIVES
The old "dilute
and disperse" concept of waste management no longer works, and
the newer concept of "concentrate and contain" is giving way to
a concept called integrated waste management. This section should
foster your understanding of concepts covered in the text regarding the
following:
- That management of hazardous chemical waste
is one of our most serious environmental concerns.
- The major pathways by which hazardous waste
pollutants from a disposal site may enter the environment.
- Problems related to ocean dumping and why
these problems are likely to persist for some time.
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUE: Should
We Dispose of Waste in the Ocean?
The New York Bight,
the coastal water off the Long Island and New Jersey shores, includes Newark
Bay, an important commercial shipping port. To keep this $20 billion
industry open to large vessels, accumulated sediments must be dredged periodically
to maintain a minimum depth of 12.8 m. Since 1976, 5.3 million cubic
meters (7 million cubic yards) a year of dredged material has been dumped
at the Mud Dump site, an area of about 5.2 square kilometers (2 square miles)
about 9.6 kilometers (6.0 miles) from shore, with an average depth
of 22 meters (72 feet). The site is in the midst of rich fishing grounds;
only 1.6 kilometers (1 mile) away is the famous 17 fathoms, a prime
fishing spot for bluefish, bonitos, false albacore, blackfish, and flukes
and the focus of a $100 million a year industry.
Much of the sediment
originates as runoff from the three rivers feeding the estuary in the bight:
the Hudson, Passaic, and Raritan. But with the sediment come many
metallic and organic toxic wastes from industries along the rivers, among
them dioxin, one of the most toxic substances known. Because dioxin
has been associated with cancer and immune deficiencies in animals
and is suspected to have many other adverse health effects, dredging the
dioxin-contaminated sediments became highly controversial in the early 1990s.
A request by the Port
Authority of New York to dredge and dump 383,000 cubic meters (500,000 cubic
yards) of contaminated sediment at the Mud Dump site was held up while questions
regarding the impact on the marine environment and human health were debated.
Differing opinions as to the lower and upper limits of moderate dioxin contamination
complicated the decision on disposal of the dredged materials. Concentrations
greater than 4 parts per trillion (pptr) would have required capping, and
ocean disposal was prohibited for concentrations above 25 pptr. Some
experts felt these limits were too liberal, but other pointed out that Europe
and Canada accepted even higher levels.
By 1991 scientists
had reached a consensus on the mechanism by which dioxin acts on living
cells and agreed on the need to question existing guidelines for safe exposure.
The average dioxin concentration various for different parts of Newark Bay,
from 39.4 pptr to 110.6 pptr. The average level in sandworms at the
Mud Dump site is 27 pptr of dry weight. Dioxin is highly fat soluble
and accumulates in fatty tissue. Predators of the sandworms and other
marine organisms can be expected to accumulate concentrations as much as
1000 times greater than those in their prey. As dioxin is passed up
a food chain, concentrations in fatty tissues of fish can be as much as
10,000 times those in the surrounding water.
.
FAQs
.
Photo Credit: US EPA |