BUILDING APPLICATION FRAMEWORKS: OBJECT-ORIENTED FOUNDATIONS OF FRAMEWORK DESIGN


Acknowledgements

This book would not have been possible without the help of many great people. We are grateful to all the authors for their submissions and their patience, and to all the reviewers for valuable and useful reviews. Mohamed Fayad would like to take this opportunity to say that it was an honor to work with the other two editors for this book, Douglas Schmidt and Ralph Johnson, and with all the authors and reviewers. This was a wonderful and enjoyable project because of your tremendous help and extensive patience.

The editors wish to thank all of those who have had a part in the production of this book. First, and foremost, we owe our families a huge debt of gratitude for being so patient while we have put their world in a whirl by injecting this writing activity into their already full lives. We also thank the various reviewers and editors that have helped in so many ways putting the book together. We thank our associates who have offered their advice and wisdom in defining the content of the book. We also owe a special thanks to those who have worked on the various projects covered in the case studies and examples.

Mohamed Fayad: "A special thanks to my wife Raefa, my lovely daughters: Rodina and Rawan, and my son Ahmad for their great patience and understanding. Special thanks to my friend Mauri Laitinen for his encouragement and long discussion about the topics and the issues in this book. Thanks to all my students, in particular Amr Yassin and Jinkun Hu, David Naney, Sanjeev Sagen, and Adam Altman to my friend Jun Gu, Marshall Cline, W.T. Tsai, Solomon Gabraiel, Abd AlAziz Khamis, and Yasser alSafadi for their encouragement during this project, and to the Communications of ACM staff -- Diana Crawford, Tom Lambert, and Robert Fox for their support."

 

Contributors

We thank all the following contributors for their tremendous effort and patience in making this volume a reality. We also thank all the contributors who participated in the review process for their valuable comments and excellent reviews. This volume provides a unique source and a wide spectrum of knowledge to aid software vendors, managers, developers, and users in their journey to manage, develop, adapt, and utilize application and enterprise frameworks. It is an appropriate book for a variety of graduate courses in advanced software engineering, reuse, framework technology and others. It is also a single source for conducting research in component-based reuse and object-oriented application and enterprise frameworks. It was a great honor to work with all of you. The volume was made possible only by the enormous efforts of the contributors; we sincerely thank all you:

 

Mehmet Aksit

University of Twente, The Netherlands

 

Paulo S.C. Alencar

University of Waterloo, Canada

 

Jagdish Bansiya

Southern Polytechnic State University, USA

 

Dirk Bäumer

Object Technology International, Switzerland

 

PerOlof Bengtsson

University of Karlskrona/Ronneby, Sweden

Lodewijk Bergmans

University of Twente, The Netherlands

 

Joan Boone

IBM Corporation, USA

 

Jan Bosch

University of Karlskrona/Ronneby, Sweden

R J A Buhr

Carleton University, Canada

 

Gregory Butler

Concordia University, Canada

 

Susan G. Carpenter

IBM Corporation, USA

 

Marshall Cline

MT Systems, USA

 

Don Cowan

University of Waterloo, Canada

 

Pierre Dénommée

Concordia University, Canada

 

Desmond F. D'Souza

ICON Computing, USA

 

Jutta Eckstein

Consultant, Germany

 

John M. Favaro

Intecs Sistemi S.p.A, Italy

 

Kenneth R. Favaro

Marakon Associates, UK

 

Marcus F. Fontoura

PUC-Rio, Brazil

 

Garry Frioehlich

University of Alberta, Canada

 

Alejandra Garrido

University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, USA

Mike Girou

MT Systems, USA

 

Michael Goedicke

University of Essen, Germany

 

Guido Gryczan

University of Hamburg, Germany

 

David Hamu

TRW, USA

 

H. James Hoover

University of Alberta, Canada

 

Eyõun Eli Jacobsen

The Maersk Mc-Kinney Moller Institute for Production Technology, University of Southern Denmark, Denmark

 

Art Jolin

IBM Corporation, USA

 

Steven R. Jones

ISA Services, USA

 

Graham King

Southampton Institute, UK

Rolf Knoll

RWG GmbH, Germany

 

Kai Koskimies

Tampere University of Technology, Finland

 

Mauri Laitinen

Laitinen Consulting, USA

 

Dave Lavin

Object Technology International, USA

 

Carola Lilienthal

University of Hamburg, Germany

 

Ling Liu

University of Alberta, Canada

 

Carlos J.P. Lucena

PUC-Rio, Brazil

 

Melissa L. Major

Software Architects, USA

Boris Magnusson,

Lund Institute of Technology, Sweden

 

Francesco Marcelloni

Universita` degli Studi di Pisa, Italy

 

Michael Mattsson

University of Karlskrona/Ronneby, Sweden

John D. McGregor

Clemson University & Software Architects, USA

 

James C. McKim, Jr.

Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, USA

 

Torsten Meyer

University of Essen, Germany

 

Granville G. Miller

Make Systems, USA

 

Hafedh Mili

Université du Québec à Montréal, Canada

 

Peter Molin

University of Karlskrona/Ronneby, Sweden

Torsten Nelson

University of Waterloo, Canada

 

Palle Nowack

The Maersk Mc-Kinney Moller Institute for Production Technology, University of Southern Denmark, Denmark

 

Wolfgang Pree

University of Constance, Germany

 

David C. Raines

Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, USA

 

Paolo Predonzani

DIST - Universita' di Genova, Italy

 

Dirk Riehle

UBS AG, Switzerland

 

Gustavo Rossi

University of La Plata, Argentina

 

Andreas Rüping
sd&m software design & management GmbH & Co.KG, Germany

Houari Sahraoui

Centre de Recherche Informatique de Montréal, Canada

 

Hans Albrecht Schmid

University for Applied Research, Konstanz, Germany

 

Paul Sorenson

University of Alberta, Canada

 

Neelam Soundarajan

Ohio State University, USA

 

Giancarlo Succi

The University of Calgary, Canada

 

Bedir Tekinerdogan,

University of Twente, The Netherlands

Andrea Valerio

DIST - Universita' di Genova, Italy

 

Jean Vaucher

Université De Montréal, Canada

 

Tullio Vernazza

DIST - Universita' di Genova, Italy

 

Alan Cameron Wills

TriReme International Ltd, UK

 

Wang Yingxu

IVP Centre for Software Engineering, Sweden

 

Howard Young

IBM Corporation, USA

 

Heinz Züllighoven

University of Hamburg, Germany

 

Reviewers

We would like to give a special thanks to all the reviewers for their useful reviews, helpful critiques, and invaluable insights that have resulted in a clearer presentation and more integrated book than anything that the editors could do alone. This manuscript is one of three-volume work on frameworks and has been thoroughly reviewed by more than 500 reviewers. Reviewer comments contributed immeasurably to the making of this book. As editors, we have been honored to work with all of you and let me assure you that all your valuable comments have led to improvements in the content and presentation of this book. Thank you all. We wish to recognize:

 

Amund Aarsten

Politecnico di Torino, Italy

 

Gregory Abowd

Georgia Institute of Technology, USA

 

Muhammad S. Al-Mulhem

King Fahd University, Saudi Arabia

 

Khalid Al-Tawil

King Fahd University, Saudi Arabia

 

Bruce Ambler

Lucent Technologies, USA

 

Dana L. G. Anthony

Knowledge Systems Corporation, USA

 

Semyon Axelrod

Born, USA

 

Chris Baas

IC Group, The Netherlands

 

Peter C. Bahrs

IBM Corporation, USA

 

Guruduth Banavar

IBM Corporation, USA

 

Leonor Barroca

The Open University, UK

 

Naser S. Barghouti

Bear Stearns & Co., USA

 

Len Bass

SEI, USA

 

Derek Beatty

Motorola, USA

Mark W Beall

RPI, USA

 

Fábio Beckenkamp

University of Constance, Germany

Kent Beck

Consultant, USA

 

Peter Beijderwellen

Origin/Nieuwegein B.V, The Netherlands

 

Kevin M. Benner

United HealthCare Corporation, USA

 

Steve Berczuk

Netsuite Development Corporation, USA

 

Katherine Betz

IBM Corporation, USA

 

Kyle Brown

Knowledge Systems Corp., USA

 

Bent Bruun Kristensen

Odense University, Denmark

 

Davide Brugali

Politecnico di Torino, Italy

 

Barrett Bryant

The University of Alabama at Birmingham, USA

 

Frank Buschmann

Siemens AG, Germany

 

Vinny Cahill

Trinity College Dublin, Ireland

 

Giuseppe Calavaro

N/A

 

Roy H. Campbell

University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, USA

 

Marcelo Campo

Braziel

 

C. Canal

University of Malaga, Spain

 

Miriam A. M. Capretz

Japan

 

Luiz Fernando Capretz

Japan

 

Riccardo Capobianchi

France

 

Denis Carcagno

France

 

Todd Carrico

N/A

 

K. Mani Chandy

Caltech, USA

 

M. Chaudhry

University of MO, Kansas City, USA

 

Ian Chang

Microsoft Corp., USA

 

Sally Chan

Boeing, USA

 

D.J. Chen

Tiawan

 

Sao-Jie Chen

National Taiwan University, Tiawan

 

Paul Clements

Software Engineering Institute, USA

 

Wim Codenie

OO Partners, Belgium

 

Sholom Cohen

SEI, USA

 

Chris Grimes

USA

 

Robert M. Cubert

University of Florida, USA

 

 

Arco Dalebout

The Netherlands

Bill Gardner

University of Victoria, Canada

 

Dennis DeBruler

Lucent Technologies, USA

 

Jean-Marc Debaud

Fraunhofer Institute for Experimental Software Engineering, Germany

 

Chris Dee

Logica UK

 

David E. DeLano

AG Communication Systems, USA

 

Serge Demeyer

University of Berne, The Netherlands

 

Adriano DeOliveira

USA

 

Beat Liver

Swiss TELECOM PTT, Switzerland

 

Brad A. Myers

Carnegie Mellon University, USA

 

Martine Devos

AGRO, Belgium

 

Wally Dietrich

IBM Corporation, USA

 

 

Christophe Dony

LIRMM, Montpellier-II University, France

 

Dov Dori

Technion - Israel Institute of Technology, Israel

 

Juergen Dorn

Technische Universitaet Wien, Austria

 

David Doscher

Sematech, USA

 

Richard T. Due

Consultant, Canada

 

Daniel Dvorak

Jet Propulsion Lab, Caltech, USA

 

Ayman EL-Dessouki

Electronics Research Institute, Egypt

Tzilla Elrad

Illinois Institute of Technology (IIT), USA

 

Jonathan Engelsma

Motorola, USA

 

Hakan Erdogmus

Canada

 

Karin Erni

Denmark

 

Rob Farmelo

HP, USA

 

David Feldt

All State, USA

 

Shawn Ferriss

Intel, USA

 

Paul A. Fishwick

University of Florida, USA

 

Peter Fischer

USA

 

Brian Foote

University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, USA

 

Martin Fowler

Consultant, USA

 

Michael Franz

USA

 

Annick FRON

Consultant, Frence

 

Lidia Fuentes

University of Malaga, Span

 

Erich Gamma

Object Technology International

 

Steve Garone

International Data Corporation

 

Amy S. Gause

Knowledge Systems Corporation, USA

Andreas Gehmeyr

Siemens AG, Germany

 

Patty Genualdi

AG Communication Systems, USA

 

Debra Gesimondo

Cambridge Technology Partners, USA

 

Greg P. Gibson

AG Communication Systems, USA

 

Jim Godwin

T&PC, USA

 

Michael Goedicke

Informatik.uni-essen, Denmark

 

Adele Goldberg

Neometron, USA

Charles Weir

UK

 

Christopher Moore

Parcplace, USA

Clemens Szyperski

Australia

 

Sanjiv Gossain

Cambridge Technology Partners, UK

Jeff Gray

Vanderbilt University, USA

 

R. W. Griffiths

The Open University, UK

 

Rachid GUERRAOUI

EPFL

 

Mohsen Guizani

King Fahd University, Saudi Arabia

 

Fuyin (F.) Guo

Nortel Technology, Canada

 

Jurg Gutknecht

ETH Zentrum, Switzerland

 

Robert Hanmer

Lucent Technologies, USA

 

Neil Harrison

Lucent Technologies, USA

 

Sandi Haselman

Capital One Services, USA

 

Saniya Ben Hassen

IBM Corporation, Europe

 

Rick Hayes-Roth

Teknowledge, USA

 

Gorel Hedin

Aarhus University, Denmark

 

Daniel Heiniger

N/A

 

James E Heliotis

RIT, USA

 

Pedro Rangel Henriques

Universidade do Minho, Portugal

 

 

Sallie Henry

Virginia Tech, USA

 

Jos van Hillegersberg

The Netherlands

 

Robert Hodges

Texas Instruments, USA

 

 

S. Holland

The Open University, UK

 

Glenn Hollowell

Texas Instruments, USA

 

Wade Holst

University of Alberta, Canada

 

Koen De Hondt

N/A

 

HEn-Hsin Huang

ITT, USA

 

Eric Hughes

The MITRE Corporation, USA

 

James C. Hu

Entera, Inc., USA

 

Jinkun Hu

Philips Research

 

Bruce Hyre

Knowledge Systems Corporation, USA

 

Chris Jacobson

GemStone Systems, USA

 

 

JAL Ghinwa Jalloul

American University, Lebnan

 

David A. Janello

AllState, USA

 

W.J. Jansen

The Netherlands

 

Tom Jell

Siemens AG, Germany

 

Jean-Marc Jezequel

IRISA, France

 

Gary Johnston

IBM Corporation, USA

 

Art Jolin

IBM Corporation, USA

 

Don Jones

PNL, USA

 

Wouter Joosen

K.U.Leuven, Belgium

 

Dejan Jovanovic

Newbridge Networks Corporation, Canada

Joseph R. Kiniry

Caltech, USA

 

Kaj Hoglund

Finland

 

Raman Kannan

Monmouth University, USA

 

Epaminondas Kapetanios

Institute for Information Systems, Switzerland

 

Arthur M. Keller

Stanford, USA

 

Rudolf K. keller

University of Montreal, Canada

 

Thomas L. Keller

PNL, USA

 

Liz Kendall

Royal Melbourne Institute Of Technology, Australia

 

Ivan Kiselev

N/A

 

Jørgen Lindskov Knudsen

University of Aarhus, Denmark

 

 

Hartmut Kocher

N/A

 

Jari Koistinen

Hewlett-Packard Laboratories, USA

 

Peter Kriens

AQute, Sweden

 

Dinesh C. Kulkarni

IBM Global Services, USA

 

 

Daniel Kunzle

N/A

 

Yau-Hwang Kuo

Tiwan

 

 

Chris Laffra

IBM Corporation, USA

 

Philippe Lalanda

Thomson, France

 

Terence L. Lammers

Boeing, USA

 

Joachim Laubsch

Hewlett-Packard, USA

 

R. Greg Lavender

University of Texas, USA

 

Doug Lea

SUNY Oswego, USA

 

 

Franck Lebastard

CERMICS, France

 

William G. Lederer

MCS, USA

 

Sai Peck Lee

N/A

 

Shiuh-Chu Lee

Tiwan

 

Wenke Lee

Columbia University, USA

 

Deborah Leishman

IBM Corporation, USA

 

 

Richard M. Librizzi

MRJ Technology Solutions, USA

 

Gary Lindstrom

Uiversity of Utah, USA

 

Stan Lippman

Walt Disney Feature Animation, USA

 

Steven Litvintchouk

The MITRE Corporation, USA

 

Beat Liver

USA

 

Cristina Lopes

XEROX Palo Alto Research Center, USA

 

Claudio Lottaz

N/A

 

Gillian Lovegrove

Staffordshire University, UK

 

Bruce W. Lowther

Micron Technology, USA

 

Wolfgang Lugmayr

Technical University of Vienna, Austria

 

Mats Lundeborg

Entra Business Objects, Sweden

 

Zakaria MAAMAR

Defence Research Establishment Valcartier, Canada

 

M.D. Macgregor

The Open University, UK

 

Stuart Maclean

Consultant, UK

 

Kai-Uwe Maetzel

UBS Information Technology Lab (Ubilab), Switzerland

 

Silvano Maffeis

SoftWired, Switzerland

 

Raam Mahadevan

Boeing, USA

 

 

Nadine Malcolm

Ascent Logic Corporation, USA

 

Vishv Malhotra <vmm@eecs.utas.edu.au>,

 

Dino Mandrioli

Politecnico di Milano, Italy

 

Pierre Marcenac

France

 

Robert Martin

Object Mentor Inc, USA

 

Alfredo Matteo

Centro ISYS, Venezuela

 

Paul E. McKenney

Sequent Computer Systems, USA

 

Anneliese von Mayrhauser

Colorado State, USA

 

Christine McKenna

Teknowledge, USA

 

Uday Mehta

Altasoft, USA

 

Theo Dirk Meijler

Baan Labs, The Netherlands

 

Giuseppe Menga

Politecnico di Torino, Italy

 

Tim Menzies

University of NSW, Australia

 

Bruno Messmer

Swiss Telecom, Switzerland

 

Torsten Meyer

informatik.uni-essen, Denmark

 

Michel Tilman

N/A

 

Joaquin Miller

Systemhouse, USA

 

Naftaly H. Minsky

Rutgers, USA

 

Daniel Miranker

University of Texas, USA

 

Anil Mishra

AT&T, USA

 

Rokia Missaoui

UQAM, Canada

 

Ralf Moeller

Informatik.uni-hamburg, Denmark

 

Hanspeter Moessenboeck

University of Linz, Austria

 

Richard Mraz

USAFA, USA

 

Rudolf Mueller

Maastricht University, The Netherland

 

Vijay Musuvathy

TPC/Metamor Worldwide, USA

 

Sanjay Nadimpall

Sequent Computer Systems, USA

 

Mark W Beall

RPI, USA

 

Pascal NEGROS

Frence

 

James Newkirk

Object Mentor, USA

 

Jill Nicola

JEN Consulting, USA

 

Pekka Nikander

Finland

 

Maria Noack

Motorola Somerset, USA

 

Aruna Nookala

3M, USA

 

Charles Norton

NASA/Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL), USA

 

Kurt Nxrmark

Aalborg University, Denmark

 

Moira Norrie

ETH Zentrum, Switzerland

 

BELKHATIR Noureddine

France

 

Jeff Oakes

The Hartford, USA

 

Alan O'Callaghan

De Montfort University, UK

 

Markku Oivo

VTT Electronics, Finland

 

Don Olson

AGCS, USA

 

Bill Opdyke

Lucent Technologies/Bell Labs Innovations, USA

 

Francois PACHET

Universite P.& M. Curie, France

 

J.-L. Pacherie

France

 

Partha pratim Pal

BBN

 

Rajendra Panwar

IBM Corporation, USA

 

Juha Parssinen

Finland

 

Peter F. Patel-Schneider

Bell Labs, USA

 

Dilip Patel

South Bank University, UK

 

Adam Pease

Teknowledge, USA

Amund Aarsten

Politecnico di Torino, Italy

 

Mor Peleg

Technion - Israel Institute of Technology, Israel

 

Louis Perrochon

Stanford University, USA

 

Yardena Peres

IBM Corporation, USA

 

Robert Pfeiffer

Reflective Software Engineering, USA

 

Cuno Pfister

Oberon microsystems, Inc., Switzerland

 

Frantisek Plasil

Charles University, Czech Republic

 

Andy Pols

Consultant, UK

 

Kevin Pollari

Anderson Consulting, USA

 

Diana Popova

University of Victoria, Canada

 

Tom Price

Braziel

 

Andreas Prodromidis

Columbia University, USA

 

Ali Rafiq

Nokia Telecomunications PTY LTD, Australia

 

Bindu Rama Rao

MCS, USA

 

Ammar Rayes

Bellcore, USA

 

David Rhodes

Rhodes Consulting & Technologies, USA

 

 

Chris Richardson

Component Systems, USA

 

Adam Rifkin

CalTech, USA

David C. Rine

George Mason University, USA

Linda Rising

AG Communication Systems, USA

 

Don Roberts

University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, USA

 

Francisco Assis Rosa

INESC, Portugal

 

Bob Royce

Arbor Intelligent Systems

 

Daniel Roy

SEI, USA

 

Pierre ROY

LAFORIA, France

 

Richard M. Rubin

Consultant, USA

 

Raj Saksena

Canada

 

Albert Schappert

Siemens AG, Germany

Alice Schafer

The MITRE Corporation, USA

 

Karen L. Schuchardt

PNL, USA

 

Hans Albrecht Schmid

University of Applied Research, Germany

 

Klaus Schmid

Fraunhofer Institute for Experimental, Germany

 

Robert Schettini

American Management Systems, USA

 

Ahmed Seffah

Computer Research Institute of Montreal , Canada

Andreas Roesel

ABB Corporate Research Heidelberg, Germany

Arnon Rosenthal

The MITRE Corporation, USA

 

Sanjeev Segan

Seimens, USA

 

Frank Seliger

IBM Deutschland Entwicklung GmbH, Germany

 

Micaela Serra

University of Victoria, Canada

 

Muhammad Shafique

King Fahd University, Saudi Arabia

 

Mark Shephard

RPI, USA

 

Dilma Menezes da Silva

University of São Paulo, BRAZIL

Antonio Rito da Silva

INESC, Portugal

 

Ian Smith

N/A

 

Savitha Srinivasan

IBM Corporation, USA

 

Verlyn M Johnson

IBM Corporation, USA

 

Chris Stary

Uinversity of Linz

 

Jim Stafford

RABA Technologies, USA

 

Ruth Stalker

N/A

 

Patrick Steyaert

MediaGeniX, Belgium

 

Duane Szafron

University of Alberta, Canada

 

Oryal Tanir

Bell Canada, Canada

 

Hugh L. Taylor

PNL, USA

 

Jean Tessier

AT&T, USA

 

Ron Ten-Hove

USA

 

J. Patrick Thompson

Microsoft, USA

 

Jon E. Thrane

Computas AS, Norway

 

Michel Tilman

Unisys Belgium

 

Frank Tip

IBM Corporation, USA

 

Ashutosh Tiwary

Boeing, USA

Steve Tockey

Rockwell Avionics & Communications, USA

 

J. M. Troya

University of Malaga, Spain

 

Pei-Lei Tu

IBM Corporation, USA

 

Paul Turner

Persistence, USA

 

Greg Utas

Nortel, USA

 

Stefan Vaillant

Nokia Telecommunications GmbH, Germany

 

Arlette Vercammen

OO Partners

 

John Vergo

IBM Corporation, USA

 

Ufuk Verun

Tellabs,

 

Sergio Viademonte

Universitaet Konstanz, Germany

 

Kateel Vijayananda

Swisscom AG, Switzerland

 

Harrick M. Vin

University of Texas, USA

 

Steve Vinoski

HP Lab, USA

 

Kerstin Voigt

California State University, San Bernardino, USA

 

Pnina Vortman

IBM Corporation, USA

 

Mark Wai

Frontier Systems Architecture, USA

 

Eugene Wallingford

Univ. of Northern Iowa, USA

 

Jin Wang

Lucent Technologies, USA

 

Yung-Hsin Wang

Tatung Institute of Technology, Taiwan

 

Eric Wegscheider

Objectquest, USA

 

Peter Wegner

Brown University, USA

Liu Wenyin

Tsinghua University, China

 

Roger K. White

Hekimian Laboratories, USA

 

Joseph White

USA

 

Gio Wiederhold

Stanford University, USA

 

Adam Wildavsky

Tame Software Inc., USA

 

Laird C. Williams

Rockwell International, USA

 

Bob Wilhelm

Objective Control, USA

 

Mark W. Windholtz

ObjectWind, USA

 

Jim Withey

Carnegie Mellon University, USA

 

Alexander Wong

Intel Technology CAD, USA

John C. Xiao

IBM Corporation, USA

 

Bobby Woolf

Consultant, USA

 

Mark Woodman

The Open University, UK

Hiroyuki Yamada

Ehime University, Japan

 

DerShung Yang

Altasoft, USA

 

Amr F. Yassin

University of Nevada, USA

 

Barbara Yates

Bytesmiths, USA

 

George M. Yee

Nortel Networks, Canada

 

Jimmie Young

Consultant, USA

 

Shyan-Ming Yuan

Tiewan

 

Bernard P. Zeigler

University of Arizona, USA

 

Dan Zimmerman

Caltech, USA

 

Gabi Zodik

IBM Corporation, USA

 

All the reviewers without exception deserve awards for their excellent comments and timely reviews. As I promised, we will award ten reviewers a copy of this book. These reviewers were drawn randomly by my youngest daughter Rawan (five years old). This is just a token of appreciation to all the reviewers. Thank you all for remarkable contributions (your reviews) to this book.

 

Mehmt Aksit

University of Twente, The Netherlands

 

Jan Bosch

University of Karlskrona/Ronneby, Sweden

Gerald Baumgartner

Ohio State University, USA

 

Hernán Austudillo R.

Universidade de São Paulo, Barzil

 

Raman Kannan

Monmouth University & GovPx, USA

 

Franklisek Plasil

Charles University, Czech Republic

 

Dirk Riehle

UBS AG, Switzerland

 

Adam Rifkin

Caltech, USA

 

Linda Rising

AG Communication Systems, USA

 

Dilma Memzes da Silva

University of São Paulo, BRAZIL

 

We are grateful to all the authors for their submission and their patience, and review committee members for valuable and useful reviews on all the submissions for ACM Computing Surveys symposium. In particular, we wish to recognize: Liz Kendall, Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology - RMIT (Australia), Juergen Dorn, Technische Universitaet Wien (Austria), Dilma Menezes da Silva, University of São Paulo (Brazil), Paulo S.C. Alencar, University of Waterloo (Canada), Zakaria Maamar, Defence Research Establishment Valcartier (Canada), Diana Popova (Canada), Giancarlo Succi, University of Calgary (Canada), Jørgen Lindskov Knudsen, University of Aarhus (Denmark), Jean-Marc Jezequel, IRISA/CNRS (Frence), Francois Pachet, SONY CSL (France), Jutta Eckstein (Germany), Liu Wenyin, Technion (Israel) & Tsinghua University (PR China), Alberto Coen-Porisini, Politecnico di Milano (Italy), Davide Brugali, Politecnico di Torino (Italy), Andrea Valerio, Universita` di Genova (Italy), Mehmet Aksit, University of Twente (The Netherlands), Lidia Fuentes Fernandez, Universidad de Malaga (Spain), Jan Bosch, University of Karlskrona/Ronneby (Sweden), Gorel Hedin, Lund University (Sweden), Rachid Guerraoui Swiss Federal Institute of Technology - SFIT (Switzerland), Ehab Al-Shaer, DePaul University (USA), Guruduth Banavar, IBM TJ Watson Research Center (USA), Sally Chan, Boeing Commercial Airplane (USA), Art Jolin, IBM (USA), Raman Kannan, Monmouth University & GovPx (USA), Dinesh Kalkarni, IBM Global Services (USA), Granville Miller, Make Systems (USA), Partha Pratim Pal, BBN Corp. (USA), Dave Rine, George Mason University (USA), Mark Wai, Frontier Systems Architecture (USA), and Jimmie Young Selectrica (USA). We would like to thank the staff of ACM Computing Surveys for their help in producing this symposium.

We are very grateful to the editors at John Wiley & Sons. Thanks to Marjorie Spencer for her belief and support of the book, to Margaret Hendrey for her patience and for helping me to bring this text together, and to Marnie Wielage for overseeing the production of such a gigantic project.


Cover
ISBN 0-471-24875-4
688 pages
September, 1999

WCP Home Page


WCP Home Page

[ Framework Foundations ] [ Implementing Frameworks ] [ Domain-Specific Frameworks ]

Copyright © 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Wiley Computer Publishing