Skip to main content

Doctors and Healers

Doctors and Healers

Tobie Nathan, Isabelle Stengers

ISBN: 978-1-509-52189-0

Aug 2018, Polity

220 pages

$18.99

Description

We think we know what healers do: they build on patients’ irrational beliefs and treat them in a ‘symbolic’ way. If they get results, it’s thanks to their capacity to listen, rather than any influence on a clinical level. At the same time, we also think we know what modern medicine is: a highly technical and rational process, but one that scarcely listens to patients at all.

In this book, ethnopsychiatrist Tobie Nathan and philosopher Isabelle Stengers argue that this commonly posed opposition between traditional and modern medicine is misleading. They show instead that healers are interesting precisely because they don’t listen to patients, using techniques of ‘divination’ rather than ‘diagnosis’. Healers construct genuine therapeutic strategies by identifying the origins of symptoms in external forces, outside of the mind of the sufferer. Modern medicine, for its part, is characterized by empiricism rather than rationality. What appears to be the pursuit of rationality is ultimately only a means to dismiss and exclude other forms of treatment.

Blurring the distinctions between traditional and modern practices and drawing on perspectives from across the globe, this ethnopsychiatric manifesto encourages us to think in radically new ways about illness, challenging accepted notions on the relationship between sufferer and symptom.

Related Resources

Instructor

Request an Evaluation Copy for this title

  • Contents
  • Editor’s Note
  • 1. Towards a Scientific Psychopathology - Tobie Nathan
  • I. The Benefits of Folk Therapy
  • Scientific Therapy and Folk Therapy
  • Solitude
  • Diagnostics or Divination
  • Statistical Categories vs. Real Cultural Groups
  • The Construction of Truth
  • Risky Psychopathology
  • A Clinical Illustration
  • Continuation of the Consultation
  • II. Medicines in Non-Western Cultures
  • Prolegomena on Thought and Belief
  • The Idea of the Symbol
  • The White Man’s Medicines
  • Thought is in Objects
  • Concepts of the Savage Mind
  • Active Objects
  • In Conclusion
  • 2. The Doctor and the Charlatan - Isabelle Stengers
  • Recovering for the Wrong Reasons
  • The Power of Experimentation
  • Who defines the causes?
  • A Practical Challenge
  • 3. Users: Lobbies or Political Creativity? - Isabelle Stengers
  • Is another kind of medicine possible?
  • Disease mongering
  • A machine
  • Condemnation?
  • Hands Off!
  • 4. Doctors, Healers, Therapists, the Sick, Patients, Subjects, UsersÉ- Tobie Nathan
  • Therapist
  • The Sick
  • Patients
  • Subjects
  • Users
  • Pharmaka
  • Notes
‘The translation of this collaboration between two leading European thinkers about psychopathology and therapeutic process gives us access to a challenging way of thinking about the relation between health and the holy, medicine and the sacred, science and religion, rationality and irrationality, psychotherapy and psychopharmacology – all in a way that will be of immediate value for those concerned with psychiatric anthropology, cultural psychiatry and global mental health.’
Thomas Csordas, University of California San Diego