Is China Buying the World?
Is China Buying the World?
ISBN: 978-0-745-66078-3 April 2012 Polity 120 Pages
Is there any truth to this idea? Or is this just scaremongering by Western commentators who have little interest in a balanced presentation of China's role in the global political economy?
In this short book Peter Nolan - one of the leading international experts on China and the global economy - probes behind the media rhetoric and shows that the idea that China is buying the world is a myth. Since the 1970s the global business revolution has resulted in an unprecedented degree of industrial concentration. Giant firms from high income countries with leading technologies and brands have greatly increased their investments in developing countries, with China at the forefront. Multinational companies account for over two-thirds of China's high technology output and over ninety percent of its high technology exports. Global firms are deep inside the Chinese business system and are pressing China hard to be permitted to increase their presence without restraints.
By contrast, Chinese firms have a negligible presence in the high-income countries - in other words, we are ‘inside them' but they are not yet ‘inside us'. China's 70-odd ‘national champion' firms are protected by the government through state ownership and other support measures. They are in industries such as banking, metals, mining, oil, power, construction, transport, and telecommunications, which tend to make use of high technology products rather than produce these products themselves. Their growth has been based on the rapidly growing home market. China has been unsuccessful so far in its efforts to nurture a group of globally competitive firms with leading global technologies and brands. Whether it will be successful in the future is an open question.
This balanced analysis replaces rhetoric with evidence and argument. It provides a much-needed perspective on current debates about China's growing power and it will contribute to a constructive dialogue between China and the West.
Table of contents
List of Tables vii
1 Who are We? Who are They? 11
2 Who are We? 15
2.1 Globalization and industrial concentration 15
2.2 Evidence from automobiles and beverages 25
2.3 Globalization and 'going out' by global firms 38
3 Who are They? 55
3.1 China catches up 55
3.2 China is still far from 'catching up' 66
3.3 China's deepening relationship with developing countries 70
3.4 Oil companies and energy security 75
3.5 Multinational companies 'going in' to China 84
3.6 Chinese fi rms 'going out' of China into the high-income economies: 'I have you within me but you do not have me within you' 95
3.7 Constraints on China 'buying the world' 102
4 The Complexity of 'Us' and 'Them': The Case of Strategic Industries 110
4.1 Banks 110
4.2 Commercial aircraft 119
Is China buying the world? 132
Who are we? 133
Who are they? 136
The complexity of catching up 142
Martin Wolf, Financial Times
"Peter Nolan knows more about Chinese companies and their international competition than anyone else on earth, including in China."
"This new book joins the debate with breath-taking depth and width, probing the very heart of the global economic system that we currently live in."
LSE Politics Blog
"A balanced and very honest analysis."
"Another excellent product of Nolan's fruitful academic career. In spite of its brevity, this highly readable yet rigorous volume closely engages many essential issues that directly concern the future of the world's economic and political orders."
"This is a useful little book; not only for its assessment of China, but also for its résumé of the globalised West and indeed worth a look for that alone."
"A well-argued rebuttal of anti-Chinese xenophobia, full of remarkable statistics."
"A slim and agile study of the eponymous question, which primarily seeks to debunk the growing myth."
''This is an analysis which replaces rhetoric on Chinese companies with evidence''
"Nolan makes a convincing case against panic. Even China's vast sovereign wealth is small compared to the market capitalisation of the companies listed on the stock exchanges of the West."
The CA Magazine
"Nolan's slim factual volume is a model of clarity."
"An important perspective that challenges popular conceptions."
"If you want to learn about large companies, their role in the global economy and in China's rise, there is no better guide than Peter Nolan: his analyses are factual, measured and persuasive."
Vaclav Smil, University of Manitoba
"There is a wealth of current information in the book. The prose is succinct. It is aimed at addressing the question of China “buying the world” in the most direct, fact based way."(Studies on Asia 2013)