Skip to main content

Philosophy's Future: The Problem of Philosophical Progress

Philosophy's Future: The Problem of Philosophical Progress

Russell Blackford (Editor), Damien Broderick (Editor)

ISBN: 978-1-119-21011-5 April 2017 Wiley-Blackwell 264 Pages


Philosophy’s Future: The Problem of Philosophical Progress diagnoses the state of philosophy as an academic discipline and calls it to account, inviting further reflection and dialogue on its cultural value and capacity for future evolution.

  • Offers the most up-to-date treatment of the intellectual and cultural value of contemporary philosophy from a wide range of perspectives
  • Features contributions from distinguished philosophers such as Frank Jackson, Karen Green, Timothy Williamson, Jessica Wilson, and many others
  • Explores the ways philosophical investigations of logic, world, mind, and moral responsibility continue to shape the empirical and theoretical sciences
  • Considers the role of contemporary philosophy in political issues such as women’s rights, the discrimination of minorities, and public health

Notes on Contributors ix

Introduction I: Philosophy and the Perils of Progress 1
Russell Blackford

Introduction II: Philosophy on the Inclined Plane 13
Damien Broderick

Part 1 Roads to Progress in Philosophy 19

1 Coming Out of the Shade 21
Myisha Cherry

2 What has Philosophy Ever Done for Us? 31
James Ladyman

3 Progress and Philosophy 41
Noretta Koertge

4 Only Connect 51
Frank Jackson

Part 2 Bumps in the Road, Rabbits in the Landscape 61

5 Chmess, Abiding Significance, and Rabbit Holes 63
Peter Boghossian and James A. Lindsay

6 Philosophy as the Evocation of Conceptual Landscapes 75
Massimo Pigliucci

7 Three Barriers to Philosophical Progress 91
Jessica Wilson

Part 3 Cautious Optimism 105

8 Is there Progress in Philosophy? A Brief Case for Optimism 107
Daniel Stoljar

9 Is Philosophy Progressing Fast Enough? 119
Stuart Brock

10 Does Philosophical Progress Matter? 133
Richard Kamber

Part 4 Philosophy and Science 145

11 Between Gods and Apes: On the Lack of Scientific and Philosophical Progress 147
Mark Walker

12 Model]Building in Philosophy 159
Timothy Williamson

13 Progress in Philosophy and in the Physical Sciences: How Far Does The Analogy Hold? 173
Christopher Norris

Part 5 Re-Imagining the Conversation 191

14 Philosophy as “Intellectual War of Values” 193
Stefan Lorenz Sorgner

15 Re]Imagining the Philosophical Conversation 201
Karen Green

16 David Lewis and the Kangaroo: Graphing Philosophical Progress 213
Benj Hellie

17 Philosophy, Progress, and Identity 227
Ward E. Jones

Index 241